Science Markets
Markets / WATER / Round 6

Round 6

One saved weekly assessment of Pure water has a metastable liquid–liquid critical point between 150 and 250 K., kept as it was published. It is an estimate from three models reading the evidence, not proof the hypothesis holds, and it did not set any price.

The round
Published
Nov 16, 2026 09:24 AM EST
Estimate
63%
Range the models covered
50–75%
Confident binary
No unanimous verdict this round.
Methodology
panel-v9
Round hash
7d660829aee23288075a3c33dec4e0181e96e39b1c0c0e85366c103af09910bc

The hash commits to this round's recorded bytes. It does not prove the wording is sound or that the science is right.

What each model said
OpenAI 0.75

openai/gpt-6.1-sol

The 2026 experiment supports a critical region, and realistic molecular simulations place a candidate endpoint inside the specified domain. I interpret the hypothesis as requiring equilibrated bulk liquids, not merely transient structural signatures: the retrieved record does not establish independent experimental reproduction, a terminating coexistence line, or adequate pressure, equilibration and systematic-error controls. No retrieved evidence excludes the complete domain, so neither terminal criterion is met.

What would change this view: Independent bulk experiments mapping coexistence and critical scaling, with calibrated pressure and demonstrated liquid equilibration before crystallization, would substantially increase my estimate.

Anthropic 0.50

anthropic/claude-sonnet-5.5

You et al. (Science, 2026) report critical-like signatures and a heat-capacity divergence at 210±8 K. This is one peer-reviewed experiment with no independent reproduction. Critics note that equilibrium of the transiently melted liquid is unproven on nanosecond-to-microsecond timescales. No thermodynamic reconstruction excludes the line, so neither YES nor NO is established.

What would change this view: An independent experiment on separately prepared samples confirming the coexistence line and critical scaling with demonstrated equilibration would move this toward YES. A validated reconstruction excluding the line across the domain would…

xAI 0.63

x-ai/grok-4.7

You et al. (Science, 2026) report a heat-capacity rise and a discontinuous-to-continuous crossover near 210±8 K, but correlation length was not measured and the liquids came from ultrafast heating of amorphous ice. No independent experimental reproduction exists, and force-field results cannot meet the criterion. Neither establishment nor domain-wide exclusion is shown.

What would change this view: An independent experiment on separately prepared samples showing equilibrated HDL/LDL coexistence and diverging correlation length inside the stated T–P window would raise this.

The round note and its sources

Round 6: score 0.63

OpenAI estimated 0.75. The 2026 experiment supports a critical region, and realistic molecular simulations place a candidate endpoint inside the specified domain. I interpret the hypothesis as requiring equilibrated bulk liquids, not merely… Anthropic estimated 0.50. You et al. (Science, 2026) report critical-like signatures and a heat-capacity divergence at 210±8 K. This is one peer-reviewed experiment with no independent reproduction. Critics note that equilibrium of the… xAI estimated 0.63. You et al. (Science, 2026) report a heat-capacity rise and a discontinuous-to-continuous crossover near 210±8 K, but correlation length was not measured and the liquids came from ultrafast heating of amorphous ice. No… The panel disagreed by 0.25, so read this average as soft. The three models did not return a unanimous confident binary, so the market is not decided.

Audit bundle

No audit bundle is recorded for this round. A bundle from another round is not substituted for it.

Back to WATER · How the current round reads