Science Markets
Markets / AXION / Round 5

Round 5

One saved weekly assessment of A QCD axion dynamically relaxes the strong-CP angle., kept as it was published. It is an estimate from three models reading the evidence, not proof the hypothesis holds, and it did not set any price.

The round
Published
Nov 16, 2026 09:02 AM EST
Estimate
29%
Range the models covered
2–50%
Confident binary
No unanimous verdict this round.
Methodology
panel-v9
Round hash
6d58e1ecef653dc6e9ea49d7300fde600d256c81e224973ae2ad029a88a4ee16

The hash commits to this round's recorded bytes. It does not prove the wording is sound or that the science is right.

What each model said
OpenAI 0.50

openai/gpt-6.1-sol

I interpret the hypothesis as asserting that this field exists, not merely that its QCD potential follows conditionally from the specified interaction. QCD calculations support the conditional mass relation, but no checked evidence establishes the required replicated gluonic-coupling and potential measurements; finite-range null searches also do not establish the contrary.

What would change this view: Independent, globally five-sigma measurements establishing the normalized gluonic coupling and QCD potential curvature and minimum would strongly increase my estimate.

Anthropic 0.02

anthropic/claude-sonnet-5.5

No axion or axion-like particle with a gluonic coupling has been detected. The criterion needs replicated 5-sigma measurements of the coupling and the QCD potential, and none exist. Searches have only excluded finite mass/coupling ranges, and no verified account of strong CP excludes the mechanism. So the evidence supports neither YES nor NO. I did not run a live search; this rests on my background knowledge of the field.

What would change this view: A replicated, peer-reviewed 5-sigma axion detection with a measured gluonic coupling and mass consistent with chi_QCD would move this toward YES. A full exclusion of dynamical axion mechanisms would move it toward NO.

No sources recorded for this answer.

xAI 0.35

x-ai/grok-4.7

No peer-reviewed, independently replicated measurement establishes a dynamical pseudoscalar with the anomaly-normalized gluonic coupling and the stated QCD minimum and curvature at ≥5σ. PDG 2025 states m_a f_a=√χ as the theoretical Peccei–Quinn definition, while CAST and ADMX report only finite-range null limits, which do not exclude the mechanism. Neither the YES detection bar nor the NO exclusion bar is met.

What would change this view: A ≥5σ independent detection of the gluonic coupling and QCD curvature, or a verified strong-CP account excluding a coexisting dynamical axion.

The round note and its sources

Round 5: score 0.29

OpenAI estimated 0.50. I interpret the hypothesis as asserting that this field exists, not merely that its QCD potential follows conditionally from the specified interaction. QCD calculations support the conditional mass relation, but no… Anthropic estimated 0.02. No axion or axion-like particle with a gluonic coupling has been detected. The criterion needs replicated 5-sigma measurements of the coupling and the QCD potential, and none exist. Searches have only excluded finite… xAI estimated 0.35. No peer-reviewed, independently replicated measurement establishes a dynamical pseudoscalar with the anomaly-normalized gluonic coupling and the stated QCD minimum and curvature at ≥5σ. PDG 2025 states m_a f_a=√χ as the… The panel disagreed by 0.48, so read this average as soft. The three models did not return a unanimous confident binary, so the market is not decided.

Audit bundle

No audit bundle is recorded for this round. A bundle from another round is not substituted for it.

Back to AXION · How the current round reads