Round 6
One saved weekly assessment of The proton's partial lifetime for positron–neutral-pion decay is below 10^35 years., kept as it was published. It is an estimate from three models reading the evidence, not proof the hypothesis holds, and it did not set any price.
- Published
- Nov 16, 2026 09:18 AM EST
- Estimate
- 23%
- Range the models covered
- 12–35%
- Confident binary
- No unanimous verdict this round.
- Methodology
- panel-v9
- Round hash
bae27c49f885883531a8b5589d0cb1678038e0b232a47d86eb543ac890c61852
The hash commits to this round's recorded bytes. It does not prove the wording is sound or that the science is right.
openai/gpt-6.1-sol
The strongest verified channel-specific result is a null search with a 90% lower limit below the stipulated boundary; it establishes neither terminal criterion. PDG’s 2025 review still reports no positive signal. The vacuum lifetime therefore remains unresolved, with no verified pair of independent qualifying measurements; detailed nuclear-correction and calibration uncertainties were not independently audited here.
What would change this view: Independent measurements with propagated nuclear uncertainties yielding either qualifying decay intervals below the boundary or 95% lower bounds above it would substantially change my estimate.
anthropic/claude-sonnet-5.5
No experiment has seen a p→e+π0 signal, so the YES condition (an established signal with a 95% interval below 1e35 yr) is unmet. The best limit is about 2.4e34 yr, below 1e35, so no analysis gives the lower bound ≥1e35 yr needed for NO. The true lifetime is unmeasured, which leaves this unresolved. I did not run a live search; this rests on recalled literature.
What would change this view: A peer-reviewed, independently reproduced signal with an interval below 1e35 yr would move this to YES. A bound ≥1e35 yr from Hyper-K or similar would move it to NO.
No sources recorded for this answer.
x-ai/grok-4.7
PDG 2025 and Super-Kamiokande (PRD 2020) report no p→e+π0 signal and a 90% CL lower limit τ/B > 2.4×10^34 yr, short of 10^35 yr. That is neither a 95% interval wholly below 10^35 yr nor a 95% lower bound at or above 10^35 yr, so neither terminal criterion is met.
What would change this view: A reproduced 95% interval wholly below 10^35 yr, or independent 95% lower limits ≥10^35 yr, would settle YES or NO.
Round 6: score 0.23
OpenAI estimated 0.35. The strongest verified channel-specific result is a null search with a 90% lower limit below the stipulated boundary; it establishes neither terminal criterion. PDG’s 2025 review still reports no positive signal. The… Anthropic estimated 0.12. No experiment has seen a p→e+π0 signal, so the YES condition (an established signal with a 95% interval below 1e35 yr) is unmet. The best limit is about 2.4e34 yr, below 1e35, so no analysis gives the lower bound ≥1e35… xAI estimated 0.22. PDG 2025 and Super-Kamiokande (PRD 2020) report no p→e+π0 signal and a 90% CL lower limit τ/B > 2.4×10^34 yr, short of 10^35 yr. That is neither a 95% interval wholly below 10^35 yr nor a 95% lower bound at or above… The panel disagreed by 0.23, so read this average as soft. The three models did not return a unanimous confident binary, so the market is not decided.
No audit bundle is recorded for this round. A bundle from another round is not substituted for it.