Science Markets
Markets / ASGARD / Round 5

Round 5

One saved weekly assessment of The eukaryotic host lineage arose within Asgard archaea., kept as it was published. It is an estimate from three models reading the evidence, not proof the hypothesis holds, and it did not set any price.

The round
Published
Nov 16, 2026 09:01 AM EST
Estimate
64%
Range the models covered
45–88%
Confident binary
No unanimous verdict this round.
Methodology
panel-v9
Round hash
840aec5fe9dcf8a54767eaa439c5bd19ee48ba9edbc8c270308e9d80b24a7da9

The hash commits to this round's recorded bytes. It does not prove the wording is sound or that the science is right.

What each model said
OpenAI 0.88

openai/gpt-6.1-sol

I interpret nesting relative to the specified four-group crown, not merely affinity with Asgard. Expanded phylogenomic analyses favor nesting, including placements outside Heimdallarchaeia, but marker and site-treatment sensitivity limits certainty. I could not verify independent datasets satisfying the exhaustive edge-placement, alternative-rooting and AU-test requirements; neither terminal conclusion is established.

What would change this view: Independent newly acquired datasets passing the complete specified placement and AU tests would establish nesting; robust rejection of every nested placement would reverse my estimate.

Anthropic 0.45

anthropic/claude-sonnet-5.5

Zhang et al. 2025 places eukaryotes as sister to Heimdallarchaeia, inside Asgard, with bootstrap above 95 on some marker sets. That is consistent with crown nesting. The criterion also needs an all-edge constrained placement search with AU tests, independent datasets, and robustness to taxon removal. I found no evidence of that. Placement is sensitive to marker set (Hodarchaeales-sister versus Heimdallarchaeia-sister), and the Liu et al. analyses allow deeper placements.

xAI 0.60

x-ai/grok-4.7

Zhang et al. 2025 place eukaryotes within Asgardarchaeota, often as Heimdallarchaeia-sister with bootstrap >95 on S97, a nested crown placement. Liu et al. 2021 recover either within-Asgard or deeper archaeal positions depending on markers and taxa. Required every-edge site-heterogeneous AU tests (≥10000 replicates) rejecting all nonnested candidates at p<0.01 on two independent datasets are not shown.

What would change this view: Two independent peer-reviewed ≥30-marker sets with every-edge AU tests (≥10000) rejecting all nonnested placements at p<0.01, stable to taxon removal, would support YES.

The round note and its sources

Round 5: score 0.64

OpenAI estimated 0.88. I interpret nesting relative to the specified four-group crown, not merely affinity with Asgard. Expanded phylogenomic analyses favor nesting, including placements outside Heimdallarchaeia, but marker and site-treatment… Anthropic estimated 0.45. Zhang et al. 2025 places eukaryotes as sister to Heimdallarchaeia, inside Asgard, with bootstrap above 95 on some marker sets. That is consistent with crown nesting. The criterion also needs an all-edge constrained… xAI estimated 0.60. Zhang et al. 2025 place eukaryotes within Asgardarchaeota, often as Heimdallarchaeia-sister with bootstrap >95 on S97, a nested crown placement. Liu et al. 2021 recover either within-Asgard or deeper archaeal positions… The panel disagreed by 0.43, so read this average as soft. The three models did not return a unanimous confident binary, so the market is not decided.

Audit bundle

No audit bundle is recorded for this round. A bundle from another round is not substituted for it.

Back to ASGARD · How the current round reads